Zombie Land

Activities & Ideas

Why Scenario-Based and Escape Challenges Outperform Traditional Trust Falls

By the Zombie Land Team

4 min read

What a trust fall actually tests

A trust fall asks one person to fall backward and the group to catch them. It is quick and memorable, and it tests one thing: whether you believe the people behind you will catch you. Then it is over.

Trust at work builds up differently. It comes from repeated small moments, such as a colleague sharing information on time, admitting a mistake, or asking for help without fear of looking weak. A single fall does not practice any of those habits. People who are uncomfortable with physical contact, or who have back problems, often sit it out.

What scenario challenges ask of a team

A scenario challenge gives the team a story, a goal, and a clock. A group might have to find the code to a locked room, recover an item before time runs out, or get every member past an obstacle. To finish, the team has to:

  • Share what each person knows, because no one has all the clues
  • Divide the work and agree on who does what
  • Change the plan when something goes wrong
  • Make decisions with incomplete information and a running timer

Teams use the same skills in a product launch, a client crisis, or a month-end close.

Psychological safety shows up under pressure

Harvard Business School professor Amy Edmondson's research on psychological safety describes teams where people feel safe to speak up, ask questions, and admit mistakes. Google's Project Aristotle, a study of its own teams, found psychological safety was the most important factor separating its effective teams from the rest.

Scenario challenges make this visible. When the clock is running and a clue is missing, you can see who speaks up, who gets talked over, and whether the group listens to the quiet person who noticed the answer. A facilitator can point those moments out in the debrief while everyone still remembers them.

Sources: Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams, by Amy Edmondson (1999), Administrative Science Quarterly [1]; Understand team effectiveness (Project Aristotle), Google re:Work [2]

The debrief is where the value is

Any activity is only as useful as the conversation after it. A trust fall gives the group little to talk about. A 45-minute escape challenge gives it a full story: the plan, the moment it failed, the person who fixed it, and the argument that wasted five minutes.

Good debrief questions are specific:

  • When did the team first get stuck, and what got you moving again?
  • Who had information that the team did not use?
  • How did the team decide who would lead?
  • What would you do differently in the next round?
  • Where does this happen at work?

A story gets people to commit

A scenario with a story, such as a zombie outbreak or a race to recover a cure, gives people permission to play. Colleagues who would never act silly in a conference room will shout across a room to warn a teammate when the story asks them to.

That level of commitment produces honest behavior, and honest behavior gives the debrief something real to work with.

How to pick a good scenario challenge

Look for these when you compare providers:

  • A clear objective that the whole team understands
  • Information split across team members, so they have to talk
  • A time limit that creates pressure without being impossible
  • Roles for different fitness levels and personalities
  • A trained facilitator who watches and runs the debrief
  • More than one round, so the team can try again with a better plan

Sources

  1. [1]Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams, by Amy Edmondson (1999). Administrative Science Quarterly.https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
  2. [2]Understand team effectiveness (Project Aristotle). Google re:Work.https://rework.withgoogle.com/intl/en/guides/understand-team-effectiveness

Common questions

Are trust falls still used in team building?

Some groups still use them as a quick warm-up, but many HR teams have moved to activities that last longer and give the group more to discuss, such as escape rooms and scenario challenges.

What is a scenario-based team building activity?

An activity that places a team inside a story with a goal and a time limit, such as escaping a locked room or recovering an item. The team has to share information, divide roles, and adapt as the scenario changes.

What is psychological safety?

A term from Amy Edmondson's research for a team climate where people feel safe to speak up, ask questions, and admit mistakes without fear of embarrassment or punishment.

Source: Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams, by Amy Edmondson (1999), Administrative Science Quarterly [1]

Planning a team day in Manila?

Tell us your headcount, preferred dates, and what you want your team to take back to the office. Our team will reply with a proposal and available dates.